Compare the plans on what may actually leave your wallet: premiums, medical bills, and the estimated tax value of an HSA contribution.
Use annual amounts from each plan’s Summary of Benefits and Coverage. For medical costs, enter your estimate of in-network allowed or negotiated charges before the plan pays; this is a simplified comparison, not a claim estimate.
HSA assumption
This calculator estimates tax savings at a 22% marginal tax bracket: HSA contribution × 0.22.
Estimated annual cost
Lower estimated total
HDHP
Lower cost
Annual premium
Medical out-of-pocket
Estimated HSA tax savings
PPO
Lower cost
Annual premium
Medical out-of-pocket
HSA tax savings
Not applied
Three spending scenarios
See which plan comes out ahead as medical spending changes.
Honed Money provides calculators and educational information for general purposes only. It is not financial, tax, legal, investment, or insurance advice. Estimates are based on the information you enter and the assumptions shown. Actual results will vary. For taxes, retirement, and government benefits, verify with IRS.gov, SSA.gov, or VA.gov. We don’t sell financial products and aren’t paid for calculator results. Use at your own risk.